Brady vs Manning

[Swampdog]

A football writer named Brad Oremland has recently published his list of the Best Quarterbacks in History. Oremland has produced an impressive, comprehensive analysis of his top 100 QB's, with specific commentary on the top 52. This is probably the best list I have ever seen, and I have read a lot of Top 10, Top 20 "greatest" lists. I don't say that this list is the best because I agree with all his rankings. I do not always agree. But I can certainly respect the time and effort that went into this type of undertaking.

Sadly, over the past 2-3 days, the comments section has deteriorated into a Brady vs Peyton Manning debate, and that is not the highlight of the composition, by any means, unless you like that sort of thing. I do, and I am guilty along with some others of moving the discussion from Oremlands work to Brady v Manning, which I slightly regret.

Anyway, the post can be found here...

http://www.footballperspective.com/g...n-history-1-5/

(Hope I did that right) I bring this to these barren forums in an effort to see if, like the daughter of Jairus, they may rise from the dead (or was she just sick, in which case she was healed). Not sure what type of stimulation is required here, but I would be interested in the views of anyone who reads Oremlands list.

[Bomber Sam]

1) Johnny Unitas
2) Joe Flacco
3) Bert Jones
4) Manning family (Archie, Peyton, Eli)
5) Sonny Jurgenson

thanks for link
fwiw I think Brady/Pats are cheaters and give them no credit.

[Wassit3]

1. Joe Montana
2. Terry Bradshaw
3. Johnny Unitas
4. Bart Starr
5. Cam Newton

[dps]

1 Joe Montana
2 Sammy Baugh
3 Roger Staubach
4 Dan Marino
5 Johnny Unitas

[Alloutwar]

1. Tom Brady
2. No one else matters

[ARC_Troopa_Nate]

Alex Smith

[MichelleWie]

1. Brett Favre
2. Aaron Rodgers
3. Bart Starr
4. Lynn Dickey
5. Don Majikowski