
Originally Posted by
ragecage
I was gandering at the rankings, Frank Thomas being top 25 and Dick Allen being ahead of Hank Aaron was a surprise to me.
You do have to keep in mind that length of career is not a factor in this rankings (other than I made the cutoff point 5000 PA). And Dick Allen was an amazing offensive player.
Here are the top 25 in OPS+ w/ 3000 PA:
Code:
Rank Player OPS+ Bats
1. Babe Ruth+ 207 L
2. Ted Williams+ 191 L
3. Barry Bonds 181 L
4. Lou Gehrig+ 179 L
5. R. Hornsby+ 175 R
6. Mickey Mantle+ 172 B
Albert Pujols 172 R
8. Dan Brouthers+ 170 L
Joe Jackson 170 L
10. Ty Cobb+ 168 L
11. Jimmie Foxx+ 163 R
12. Pete Browning 162 R
Mark McGwire 162 R
14. Dave Orr 161 R
15. Stan Musial+ 159 L
16. H. Greenberg+ 158 R
Johnny Mize+ 158 L
18. Tris Speaker+ 157 L
19. Dick Allen 156 R
Willie Mays+ 156 R
Frank Thomas 156 R
22. Hank Aaron+ 155 R
Joe DiMaggio+ 155 R
Mel Ott+ 155 L
Manny Ramirez 155 R