Metsguy234's Award Choosing Project

[metsguy234]

1908
NL MVP- Honus Wagner (5-time NL MVP winner!)
AL MVP- Ty Cobb
NL Cy Young- Christy Mathewson
AL Cy Young- Ed Walsh

[metsguy234]

1909
NL MVP- Honus Wagner (6th NL MVP Award!)
AL MVP- Ty Cobb
NL Cy Young- Mordecai Brown
AL Cy Young (TIE)- Harry Krause/George Mullin

Both MVPs were clear choices, with Honus Wagner winning his 6th MetsGuy MVP award. I agonized a bit over the Cy Youngs though, as both leagues had many strong candidates. The people I was considering for each award:

NL: Mordecai Brown, Christy Mathewson, Orval Overall
AL: Harry Krause, George Mullin, Frank Smith, Addie Joss

In the NL, after much deliberation, I felt that Brown had the best overall season out of those 3.

In the AL, I originally was going to just select Krause, but after perusing Mullin's stats some more, I decided to give them a joint Cy Young Award

[metsguy234]

1910
NL MVP- Sherry Magee
AL MVP- Ty Cobb
NL Cy Young- Mordecai Brown
AL Cy Young- Ed Walsh

Magee and Cobb both were obvious choices, they let their leagues in many categories. The NL Cy Young wasn't quite as clear-cut, but I still awarded it to Mordecai Brown after not that much deliberation.

The AL Cy Young made me do something tough though. I gave an award to a pitcher who was 18-20. IMO, his other stats were just extraordinary across the board, so he deserved this award.

[metsguy234]

1911
NL MVP- Frank Schulte
AL MVP- Ty Cobb
NL Cy Young (TIE)- Christy Mathewson/Pete Alexander
AL Cy Young- Vean Gregg

[metsguy234]

1912
NL MVP- Heinie Zimmerman
AL MVP- Ty Cobb
NL Cy Young- Christy Mathewson
AL Cy Young- Walter Johnson

[metsguy234]

1913
NL MVP- Gavvy Cravath
AL MVP- Joe Jackson (Sam Crawford/Ty Cobb were a very close 2nd and 3rd)
NL Cy Young- Christy Mathewson
AL Cy Young- Walter Johnson

[ragecage]

if I was metsguy...

1912:

AL MVP: Tris Speaker
NL MVP: Johnny Evers
AL CY: Smoky Joe Wood
NL CY: Rube Marquard

My AL MVP is Tris, because even though Ty Cobb hit .409 and had the best Slugging % I cant help but take away the fact he was racist.

My NL MVP is Johnny Evers because of that famous poem, it was neato. Also Heine Zimmerman lead in most catagories and played catcher, but his name is too funny to seriously consider.

My AL Cy Young: Smoky Joe Wood had 36 wins, holy cow! Thats fantastic, Johan Santana cant even do that.

MY NL Cy Young: I love wins, he lead the league. So there it is. He also was a nice guy not racist or anything so I had to give it to him.

[metsguy234]

1914
NL MVP- Gavvy Cravath
AL MVP- Ty Cobb
FL MVP- Benny Kauff
NL Cy Young- Pete Alexander
AL Cy Young- Dutch Leonard
FL Cy Young- Russ Ford

[metsguy234]

1915
NL MVP- Pete Alexander
AL MVP- Ty Cobb
FL MVP- Benny Kauff
NL Cy Young- Pete Alexander
AL Cy Young- Walter Johnson
FL Cy Young- George McConell

[metsguy234]

1916
NL MVP- Pete Alexander
AL MVP- Tris Speaker
NL Cy Young- Pete Alexander
AL Cy Young- Babe Ruth

[metsguy234]

1917
NL MVP (TIE)- Pete Alexander and Rogers Hornsby
AL MVP- Ty Cobb
NL Cy Young- Pete Alexander
AL Cy Young- Eddie Cicotte

[metsguy234]

1918
NL MVP- Edd Roush
AL MVP- Walter Johnson
NL Cy Young- Hippo Vaughn
AL Cy Young- Walter Johnson

[metsguy234]

1919
NL MVP- Rogers Hornsby
AL MVP- Babe Ruth
NL Cy Young- Pete Alexander
AL Cy Young- Walter Johnson

[HoustonGM]

AL MVP- Walter Johnson

I can't resist. Walter Johnson was 23-13, far from 100-0!

[metsguy234]

1920
NL MVP- Rogers Hornsby
AL MVP- Babe Ruth
NL Cy Young- Pete Alexander
AL Cy Young- Stan Coveleski