A little project I'm thinking of doing (HGM's Historical MVP/Cy Young Choices)

[TheNamelessPoet]

I don't know I would wish that if I had only one wish. But I do often wish I could have seen some of these awesome players.

Ruth, Williams, Johnson... if I could only go back and see 3... they would be it. If I could see 5 id add Cobb and Probably Jackie Robbinson

[RedsoxRockies]

Ruth, Williams, Johnson... if I could only go back and see 3... they would be it. If I could see 5 id add Cobb and Probably Jackie Robbinson

What about Old Hoss and that Blue Moon guy from Field of Dreams

[TheNamelessPoet]

What about Old Hoss and that Blue Moon guy from Field of Dreams

I dont remember the blue moon buy... but I dont know if we are talking aobut the same Old Hoss... I'd like to see him but there are many Id like to see more. 300 wins in I think 7-10 yeras 59-60 in 1 season over 600 IP... yea... ill take him... he pitched somehing lik e23 or the final 25 games... and didnt even pitch the whole season.. really a remarkable guy

[metsguy234]

What about Old Hoss and that Blue Moon guy from Field of Dreams

I think you are confusing Moonlight Graham with Blue Moon Odom

[RedsoxRockies]

I dont remember the blue moon buy... but I dont know if we are talking aobut the same Old Hoss... I'd like to see him but there are many Id like to see more. 300 wins in I think 7-10 yeras 59-60 in 1 season over 600 IP... yea... ill take him... he pitched somehing lik e23 or the final 25 games... and didnt even pitch the whole season.. really a remarkable guy

Old Hoss radbourn, he pitched I believe the final 60 after returning from a suspension for drunkenness. blue Moon guy is an entirely different person.

[RedsoxRockies]

I think you are confusing Moonlight Graham with Blue Moon Odom

Yea, thats him. i knew Blue Moon was seperate, but I thought they were both Blue Moon's

[HoustonGM]

Back on topic...

I've decided to go back to 1876, the first year of the National League. Since I'll only be doing the NL, it'll be just one MVP and one Cy Young per year.

[RedsoxRockies]

Back on topic...

I've decided to go back to 1876, the first year of the National League. Since I'll only be doing the NL, it'll be just one MVP and one Cy Young per year.

You could do the Players league

[HoustonGM]

You could do the Players league

You know that the Player's League existed for one year, correct?

[RedsoxRockies]

You know that the Player's League existed for one year, correct?

Yes I do, but they still played, so you can do the awards for that one year.....

[HoustonGM]

Yes I do, but they still played, so you can do the awards for that one year.....

Are you also aware that there were a handful of other leagues as well, such as the American Association, which actually played for multiple years? The Player's League just seemed like a very odd choice to mention, given the other leagues in existence at the time. At any rate, I'm only doing the National League.

[RedsoxRockies]

Are you also aware that there were a handful of other leagues as well, such as the American Association, which actually played for multiple years? The Player's League just seemed like a very odd choice to mention, given the other leagues in existence at the time. At any rate, I'm only doing the National League.

Yes, I am aware. Why do you always assume you know everything and we know nothing? I was just throwing it out there, you don't have to get so rude about it

[EVEN11323]

Oh jeez, how was he rude about saying that? Let him do his own thing.

[RedsoxRockies]

Oh jeez, how was he rude about saying that? Let him do his own thing.

He always acts so pompous, and like he knows everything, and then rubs it in everyone's face

[boomboom]

You just read it that way, but I don't think he meant it that way. I didn't see anything wrong with the way he said it.

Anyway HGM, going back farther than 1901 seems a little extreme and if you do, I agree that doing only the NL, would be ideal.