2008 MLB Draft Review
Tampa Bay Rays, #1 Overall

Pluses:
- Best RP in the draft
- Very, very near ready
- Good power
- Decent control
- decent movement
- No health concerns
- Great fastball
Minuses:
- A RP #1 overall?
- No satidfactory #2 pitch yet
- Doesn't field his position well at all
- Not a ton of upside
Projection:
Shafer is an excellent RP prospect and the best one in this draft. He could be a Brad Lidge type that strikeouts a ton of batters as a closer, but he needs to develop some sort of second pitch if hes going to be a successful major league closer. But, drafting a closer #1 overall, even if that is a need, is questionable. (This was the Rays actual first overall pick when the computer did the draft, and I didn't know what else to give them since they don't really have any holes.)
Pittsburgh Pirates, #2 Overall

Pluses:
- Excellent all around offense
- Not too many health concerns
- Good power, contact, and eye
Minuses:
- Not very fast
- Defense is a big, big concern
Projection:
Alvarez is the best offensive prospect in this draft. He could be a .320-.330, 40 home run hitter, and post OBP's in the .400's once he develops fully. However, his defense is an enormous question mark and he may have to move to a less strenuous defensive position, such as left field. Reminds me of a young Miguel Cabrera.
Baltimore Orioles, #3 Overall

Pluses:
- Best SP prospect in the draft
- Great power
- Good control
- 3 good pitches
- No health concerns
Minuses:
- Lacks movement
- Doesn't field position
Projection:
Easily the best SP prospect in this draft. Already has great power and solid control, and three pitches that project very well. Will need to improve his movement to reach his potential. Could be a Cy Young winner down the road.
Kansas City Royals, #4 Overall

Pluses:
- Great power
- Great control
- Fastball and curve are very good
Minuses:
- Movement isn't good at all
- Health could be a little concern
- Lacks a third pitch
Projection:
Probably the second best SP behind Crow in this draft. Very good power, and almost equally good control. His curve and fastball both should be very, very good pitches at the ML level, but he'll probably need a third pitch as well. Movement is very lacking.
Florida Marlins, #5 Overall

Pluses:
- Very good power and control
- Good fastball and sinker
Minuses:
- Poor movement
- Health concerns
Projection:
One of the top three starting pitching prospect in this draft. Very, very advanced for a 17 year old. Should develop into a #1, or #2 starter at worst.
Fresno Outlaws, #6 Overall

Pluses:
- Has game-changing speed
- Excellent contact hitter
- Solid power hitter
- Good eye
- No health concerns
- Fields position well
- Strong arm
- Near ready
Minuses:
- At 6'2" he could outgrow the position
- Range could be a question mark
- Eye and power may not come along as expected
- Defense may not improve enough to warrant keeping him at shortstop
Projection:
Brandon projects very, very well. He could become a .310-.330 hitter, with the potential to steal 50 or more bases. In addition, he could even hit as many as 25-30 homers and post a .400 OBP, and if his defense comes along as expected he could also be a Gold Glove defender. 10 years from now he very well could be the best player to come out of this draft.
San Francisco Giants, #7 Overall

Pluses:
- Good all-around offense
- Excellent eye
- No health concerns
- Solid fielder, project well
Minuses:
- Not much range
- Not very fast
- Offensive game not well suited for LF
Projection:
Well balanced offensive game. Good contact, power, and eye. Could become a .310, 30 home run, .410 OBP type. Solid defender. His offensive value may require a switch to RF, however.
Brooklyn Crusaders, #8 Overall

Pluses:
- Tons of power
- Good eye
- No health concerns
Minuses:
- Contact hitting could be an issue
- Defense is questionable
Projection:
Has loads of power. Could be a 40+ home run hitter. His contact hitting is a bit of a concern, may only be a .270-.280 hitter at best.
Chicago White Sox, #9 Overall

Pluses:
- Well rounded offensive game
- Advanced for an 18 year old
- No health concerns
Minuses:
- Defense could be a big issue, could prompt position change
Projection:
Very good offensive prospect. Could become a .300, 30 homer, 30 steal type player. However, defense could be a problem, could lead to a switch to the outfield down the road.
Cincinnati Reds, #10 Overall

Pluses:
- Solid offensive player
- Extremely good defensive catcher
- No health problems
Minuses:
- Not very fast
- Offense may not be any better than below average once fully developed
Projection:
Should be a solid offensive catcher. Could hit .270-.280 with 20-25 homers at the major league level. His real strength is his defense. Could be a Gold Glove defensive catcher.