
Originally Posted by
HoustonGM
The one draft in Moneyball is still just one draft, and you can't draw any conclusions about the intelligence of one man based off one draft....but still, the 2002 A's draft produced 9 players that have made it to the major leagues (10 if you include Mark Kiger who only played in the playoffs). One has developed into a star - Jonathan Papelbon - but the A's didn't sign him. 3 others developed into quality major leaguers - Nick Swisher, Joe Blanton, and Mark Teahen.
Going through some other teams, the number of MLB'ers they drafted that year, regardless of whether they signed or not...
So, considering that the A's 2002 draft produced more major leaguers than any other team, and it produced more solid or better major leaguers (4) than most teams produced major leaguers, regardless of quality, I'd say that the A's 2002 draft was extremely good.
Which may have been your point, but still...you need to look at more than just one draft, considering "general managerial genius" includes free agency, player development, trading, etc.