How do you judge a hall of fame QB? Wins and losses? Passing numbers? Passer rating? take a look at the career, so far, of this QB, then take a look at his teams record during his career, then vote, is he hall of fame material or not.
Printable View
How do you judge a hall of fame QB? Wins and losses? Passing numbers? Passer rating? take a look at the career, so far, of this QB, then take a look at his teams record during his career, then vote, is he hall of fame material or not.
ok, forum isnt allowing me to upload
ok, finally able to upload.
I don't like his team's performance.
Granted, that shouldn't be the only indication of whether this QB is worthy, but I can't say he really changed the game or was at the best at his position. Not with those records.
19 tds in 9 games nice
close vote
Look at his interception rate...ouch. I say no.
For the most part, I do take team performance in to account, but the guy has 45000 yards and 346 TDs. That's like a baseball player with 500 homers, a career .310 average, and 3000 RBIs. He's a LOCK.
true, he is like a football version of dave kingman..Quote:
Originally Posted by CatKnight
is it a no because of the int's or it's a no because of the int's given his won/loss record? remeber Brett Favre has a high int rate but he is a HOFer ...Quote:
Originally Posted by boomboom
Dont know, the changing point for me is his teams performance. His team did bad which means he didnt have a great supporting cast. That for make makes him HOF worthy. It's the opposite of Tom Brady, sure he's good with the all-star team of the Patriots but put him on the a worse team like a Raiders and he probably doesnt do good.
Brady hasn't really had any all stars until this year...Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Sox Fan 734
I would say he is in. he will end up with over 50,000 passing yards and close to 400 TD's, with a career passer rating of 93. those are definately hall of fame numbers.
What "interception rate?"Quote:
Originally Posted by boomboom
Well, by using his career statistics for both touchdowns and interceptions, it looks like has a td/int ratio of 1.5Quote:
Originally Posted by Coach Owens
So, he throws 1.5 TD's for every INT.
Is this how Matt Ryan's career will play out? I need to know for my fantasy draft next year.
Are you serious? There is no way you should EVER be picking a rookie QB in fantasy football. Chances are he'll be on a pretty weak team, and he might not even play all that much his first year. If you're so desperate you are taking Matt Ryan this year, you have REALLY botched your draft. :DQuote:
Originally Posted by Robadiah
Maybe he's talking about a fantasy draft for FM ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by Arctic Blast
I'd say for both.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wassit3
Quote:
Originally Posted by Coach Owens
lolQuote:
Originally Posted by p8ntball370
i agree for that reason....Quote:
Originally Posted by boomboom
I just wanted to quote this because it made me laugh. Corey Dillon, Troy Brown, Matt Light, Richard Seymour, Deion Branch, Tedy Bruschi, Ty Law, Willie McGinest, Rodney Harrison, etc. aren't stars...riiight. :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Wassit3
Oh, and for the record, I say Ryan's a HOFer. 3rd all-time in TD passes, 7th in yards, 4th in passer rating. Plus the INT ratio (INT/pass attempt) is better than Johnny Unitas, Archie Manning, Bob Griese, Terry Bradshaw and Joe Namath. Not to mention he has the same number of Super Bowl rings as Dan Marino. :)
First off, I wouldn't even count any of the defensive guys you mentioned, as they aren't stars WITH Brady, since they aren't on the field with him, which is what I believe the earlier poster was talking about. As for the offensive guys...Quote:
Originally Posted by Brandon21
Matt Light - very few offensive linemen are true star players. Ogden, Pace and Walter Jones are a few of the rare ones that are. Matt Light is not one of them.
Deion Branch - Ummm...seriously? He didn't have a single season with 80 catches, 1000 yards, or more than 5 touchdowns during his time in New England...that's not a start receiver. He also doesn't demand double coverage, which is the mark of a star wideout.
Corey Dillon - Good running back...nothing more, nothing less. Not even close to being in the top 5 backs in the league at any time in his career.
340 TDs and 45,000 yards. I think you have to give him a vote.
He sure looks like it from a stats point, I mean they must have an atrocious Defense, look at his 2013 #'s 30-15 TD-INT, 61 Comp, 3700 yards and They went 4-12!!!! so his team performance isnt a huge factor.