How do you judge a hall of fame QB? Wins and losses? Passing numbers? Passer rating? take a look at the career, so far, of this QB, then take a look at his teams record during his career, then vote, is he hall of fame material or not.
Printable View
How do you judge a hall of fame QB? Wins and losses? Passing numbers? Passer rating? take a look at the career, so far, of this QB, then take a look at his teams record during his career, then vote, is he hall of fame material or not.
ok, forum isnt allowing me to upload
ok, finally able to upload.
I don't like his team's performance.
Granted, that shouldn't be the only indication of whether this QB is worthy, but I can't say he really changed the game or was at the best at his position. Not with those records.
19 tds in 9 games nice
close vote
Look at his interception rate...ouch. I say no.
For the most part, I do take team performance in to account, but the guy has 45000 yards and 346 TDs. That's like a baseball player with 500 homers, a career .310 average, and 3000 RBIs. He's a LOCK.
true, he is like a football version of dave kingman..Quote:
Originally Posted by CatKnight
is it a no because of the int's or it's a no because of the int's given his won/loss record? remeber Brett Favre has a high int rate but he is a HOFer ...Quote:
Originally Posted by boomboom
Dont know, the changing point for me is his teams performance. His team did bad which means he didnt have a great supporting cast. That for make makes him HOF worthy. It's the opposite of Tom Brady, sure he's good with the all-star team of the Patriots but put him on the a worse team like a Raiders and he probably doesnt do good.
Brady hasn't really had any all stars until this year...Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Sox Fan 734
I would say he is in. he will end up with over 50,000 passing yards and close to 400 TD's, with a career passer rating of 93. those are definately hall of fame numbers.
What "interception rate?"Quote:
Originally Posted by boomboom
Well, by using his career statistics for both touchdowns and interceptions, it looks like has a td/int ratio of 1.5Quote:
Originally Posted by Coach Owens
So, he throws 1.5 TD's for every INT.